Washington photometry of globular cluster giants: The most metal-poor clusters

Doug Geisler, Dante Minniti, Juan J. Claria

Resultado de la investigación: Article

21 Citas (Scopus)

Resumen

We present photometry on the Washington system for 125 stars in 10 of the most metal-poor Galactic globular clusters. Luminosity class, temperature, and metal abundance are derived for each star. A new temperature calibration is presented, based on recent model atmosphere calculations by Bell & Gustafsson [MNRAS, 236, 653 (1989)]. Metal abundances are determined utilizing a recently improved calibration which corrects for the decreased metallicity sensitivity of cooler giants and introduces a new temperature index, which significantly reduces the effects of photometric errors and reddening uncertainties in determining abundances for very metal-poor stars. Nevertheless, the derived abundances are rather uncertain due to the high reddening and photometric error sensitivities of the system for cool, metal-poor stars and because reddenings are large and/or poorly known for several of the clusters. For NGC 6397, M15, M30, and M55, the abundances are well determined (uncertainties of 0.2-0.3 dex, including internal and reddening errors) and in very good agreement with the abundance scale of Zinn [ApJ, 293, 424 (1985)]. For five other clusters, including M68 and NGC 2298, 4833, 5897, and 6101, we derive metallicities that are substantially less than those given by Zinn, although the uncertainties are larger, typically 0.3-0.5 dex. The discrepancies are particularly significant for NGC 5897 and 6101, which have small and relatively well-determined reddenings and derived metallicities as much as 0.8 dex lower than nominal values, with [Fe/H]∼ -2.5. Since the Washington and Zinn metallacity scales are shown to be in good overall agreement, we discuss in detail possible reasons for the individual discrepancies. Reddening and photometric errors, and expected errors in the respective calibrations can account for most of these, although we cannot rule out the possibility that at least several of these clusters are indeed substantially more metal deficient than previously indicated. The likelihood of intermediate metallicities for some of the discrepant clusters is discussed. Confirmation of the metal abundances of these clusters must await the results of detailed spectroscopic studies now underway. We also derive new (B - V)0,g values for a large sample of metal-poor clusters and show that this parameter loses abundance sensitivity below [Fe/H]∼ -1.85, regardless of the metallicity scale used or the (B-A)0,g source.

Idioma originalEnglish
Páginas (desde-hasta)627-644
Número de páginas18
PublicaciónAstronomical Journal
Volumen104
N.º2
EstadoPublished - ago 1992

Huella dactilar

metal clusters
globular clusters
photometry
metal
metallicity
metals
stars
calibration
sensitivity
temperature
coolers
bells
luminosity
atmospheres
atmosphere
approximation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Space and Planetary Science
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics

Citar esto

Geisler, Doug ; Minniti, Dante ; Claria, Juan J. / Washington photometry of globular cluster giants : The most metal-poor clusters. En: Astronomical Journal. 1992 ; Vol. 104, N.º 2. pp. 627-644.
@article{3bc6ccbc5c084d4fb23853a1506590ea,
title = "Washington photometry of globular cluster giants: The most metal-poor clusters",
abstract = "We present photometry on the Washington system for 125 stars in 10 of the most metal-poor Galactic globular clusters. Luminosity class, temperature, and metal abundance are derived for each star. A new temperature calibration is presented, based on recent model atmosphere calculations by Bell & Gustafsson [MNRAS, 236, 653 (1989)]. Metal abundances are determined utilizing a recently improved calibration which corrects for the decreased metallicity sensitivity of cooler giants and introduces a new temperature index, which significantly reduces the effects of photometric errors and reddening uncertainties in determining abundances for very metal-poor stars. Nevertheless, the derived abundances are rather uncertain due to the high reddening and photometric error sensitivities of the system for cool, metal-poor stars and because reddenings are large and/or poorly known for several of the clusters. For NGC 6397, M15, M30, and M55, the abundances are well determined (uncertainties of 0.2-0.3 dex, including internal and reddening errors) and in very good agreement with the abundance scale of Zinn [ApJ, 293, 424 (1985)]. For five other clusters, including M68 and NGC 2298, 4833, 5897, and 6101, we derive metallicities that are substantially less than those given by Zinn, although the uncertainties are larger, typically 0.3-0.5 dex. The discrepancies are particularly significant for NGC 5897 and 6101, which have small and relatively well-determined reddenings and derived metallicities as much as 0.8 dex lower than nominal values, with [Fe/H]∼ -2.5. Since the Washington and Zinn metallacity scales are shown to be in good overall agreement, we discuss in detail possible reasons for the individual discrepancies. Reddening and photometric errors, and expected errors in the respective calibrations can account for most of these, although we cannot rule out the possibility that at least several of these clusters are indeed substantially more metal deficient than previously indicated. The likelihood of intermediate metallicities for some of the discrepant clusters is discussed. Confirmation of the metal abundances of these clusters must await the results of detailed spectroscopic studies now underway. We also derive new (B - V)0,g values for a large sample of metal-poor clusters and show that this parameter loses abundance sensitivity below [Fe/H]∼ -1.85, regardless of the metallicity scale used or the (B-A)0,g source.",
author = "Doug Geisler and Dante Minniti and Claria, {Juan J.}",
year = "1992",
month = "8",
language = "English",
volume = "104",
pages = "627--644",
journal = "Astronomical Journal",
issn = "0004-6256",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "2",

}

Washington photometry of globular cluster giants : The most metal-poor clusters. / Geisler, Doug; Minniti, Dante; Claria, Juan J.

En: Astronomical Journal, Vol. 104, N.º 2, 08.1992, p. 627-644.

Resultado de la investigación: Article

TY - JOUR

T1 - Washington photometry of globular cluster giants

T2 - The most metal-poor clusters

AU - Geisler, Doug

AU - Minniti, Dante

AU - Claria, Juan J.

PY - 1992/8

Y1 - 1992/8

N2 - We present photometry on the Washington system for 125 stars in 10 of the most metal-poor Galactic globular clusters. Luminosity class, temperature, and metal abundance are derived for each star. A new temperature calibration is presented, based on recent model atmosphere calculations by Bell & Gustafsson [MNRAS, 236, 653 (1989)]. Metal abundances are determined utilizing a recently improved calibration which corrects for the decreased metallicity sensitivity of cooler giants and introduces a new temperature index, which significantly reduces the effects of photometric errors and reddening uncertainties in determining abundances for very metal-poor stars. Nevertheless, the derived abundances are rather uncertain due to the high reddening and photometric error sensitivities of the system for cool, metal-poor stars and because reddenings are large and/or poorly known for several of the clusters. For NGC 6397, M15, M30, and M55, the abundances are well determined (uncertainties of 0.2-0.3 dex, including internal and reddening errors) and in very good agreement with the abundance scale of Zinn [ApJ, 293, 424 (1985)]. For five other clusters, including M68 and NGC 2298, 4833, 5897, and 6101, we derive metallicities that are substantially less than those given by Zinn, although the uncertainties are larger, typically 0.3-0.5 dex. The discrepancies are particularly significant for NGC 5897 and 6101, which have small and relatively well-determined reddenings and derived metallicities as much as 0.8 dex lower than nominal values, with [Fe/H]∼ -2.5. Since the Washington and Zinn metallacity scales are shown to be in good overall agreement, we discuss in detail possible reasons for the individual discrepancies. Reddening and photometric errors, and expected errors in the respective calibrations can account for most of these, although we cannot rule out the possibility that at least several of these clusters are indeed substantially more metal deficient than previously indicated. The likelihood of intermediate metallicities for some of the discrepant clusters is discussed. Confirmation of the metal abundances of these clusters must await the results of detailed spectroscopic studies now underway. We also derive new (B - V)0,g values for a large sample of metal-poor clusters and show that this parameter loses abundance sensitivity below [Fe/H]∼ -1.85, regardless of the metallicity scale used or the (B-A)0,g source.

AB - We present photometry on the Washington system for 125 stars in 10 of the most metal-poor Galactic globular clusters. Luminosity class, temperature, and metal abundance are derived for each star. A new temperature calibration is presented, based on recent model atmosphere calculations by Bell & Gustafsson [MNRAS, 236, 653 (1989)]. Metal abundances are determined utilizing a recently improved calibration which corrects for the decreased metallicity sensitivity of cooler giants and introduces a new temperature index, which significantly reduces the effects of photometric errors and reddening uncertainties in determining abundances for very metal-poor stars. Nevertheless, the derived abundances are rather uncertain due to the high reddening and photometric error sensitivities of the system for cool, metal-poor stars and because reddenings are large and/or poorly known for several of the clusters. For NGC 6397, M15, M30, and M55, the abundances are well determined (uncertainties of 0.2-0.3 dex, including internal and reddening errors) and in very good agreement with the abundance scale of Zinn [ApJ, 293, 424 (1985)]. For five other clusters, including M68 and NGC 2298, 4833, 5897, and 6101, we derive metallicities that are substantially less than those given by Zinn, although the uncertainties are larger, typically 0.3-0.5 dex. The discrepancies are particularly significant for NGC 5897 and 6101, which have small and relatively well-determined reddenings and derived metallicities as much as 0.8 dex lower than nominal values, with [Fe/H]∼ -2.5. Since the Washington and Zinn metallacity scales are shown to be in good overall agreement, we discuss in detail possible reasons for the individual discrepancies. Reddening and photometric errors, and expected errors in the respective calibrations can account for most of these, although we cannot rule out the possibility that at least several of these clusters are indeed substantially more metal deficient than previously indicated. The likelihood of intermediate metallicities for some of the discrepant clusters is discussed. Confirmation of the metal abundances of these clusters must await the results of detailed spectroscopic studies now underway. We also derive new (B - V)0,g values for a large sample of metal-poor clusters and show that this parameter loses abundance sensitivity below [Fe/H]∼ -1.85, regardless of the metallicity scale used or the (B-A)0,g source.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0039819244&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0039819244

VL - 104

SP - 627

EP - 644

JO - Astronomical Journal

JF - Astronomical Journal

SN - 0004-6256

IS - 2

ER -